Contesting a will can be a challenging and emotional process, especially once probate has been granted. You may wonder if it’s still possible to contest the will and what the legal options are. In this article, we’ll delve into whether you can contest a will after probate has been completed, and what steps you need to take if you decide to proceed.
Contesting A Will After Probate Has Been Granted
In Victoria, contesting a will after probate has been granted is indeed possible, but it can be a complex and time-sensitive process.
Probate is the legal process that confirms the validity of a will and appoints an executor to distribute the assets as per the wishes of the deceased. Once probate has been granted, the executor begins managing and distributing the estate.
However, there are still scenarios where beneficiaries, family members, or other stakeholders may have grounds to challenge the will even after this stage.
Typically, you can contest a will if you believe you have not been adequately provided for or if you suspect that there has been some undue influence, fraud, or an error during the drafting of the will.
It is essential to act quickly, as strict time limits apply. In Victoria, the usual time frame for challenging a will is within six months from the date of the probate being granted. After this period, the court may still allow a claim, but you would need to present a compelling reason for the delay.
Grounds For Contesting A Will After Probate
Several grounds can be used to contest a will even after probate has been completed. Below, we discuss some of the most common reasons:
Inadequate Provision For Family Members
Under Victorian law, specific categories of individuals have the right to contest a will if they believe they were inadequately provided for. This includes spouses, domestic partners, children, and sometimes other dependants. If you believe that the deceased failed to provide adequately for your needs, you may have grounds to contest the will, even after probate has been granted.
Undue Influence Or Fraud
Another reason for contesting a will is if you believe that the deceased was subjected to undue influence or fraud at the time of writing their will. Undue influence involves coercion, manipulation, or other forms of pressure that led the testator to create a will that does not reflect their true intentions. If fraud or forgery can be proven, it can also be grounds to invalidate the will.
Lack Of Testamentary Capacity
The deceased must have had the mental capacity to understand the implications of writing their will. If it can be shown that the deceased lacked this capacity due to illness, cognitive impairment, or other factors, you may have a valid claim to contest the will.
Errors In The Will
Errors or ambiguities in the will, such as unclear wording or conflicting clauses, can also provide grounds for contesting a will after probate. In such cases, the court may be asked to interpret the will or amend the terms to reflect the deceased’s true intentions.
The Process Of Contesting A Will After Probate
If you decide to contest a will after probate has been completed, it’s important to understand the steps involved. While the process can be daunting, seeking legal advice and support can help ensure that your claim is well-prepared and has the best chance of success.
Step 1: Seek Legal Advice
The first step is to seek professional legal advice from a wills and estates lawyer experienced in handling contested wills. They will assess the strength of your claim, help you gather necessary evidence, and guide you through the legal process.
Step 2: File A Claim With The Court
You must file an application with the Supreme Court of Victoria to initiate the process of contesting a will. This application should outline your reasons for challenging the will, provide supporting evidence, and indicate your relationship to the deceased.
Step 3: Notify The Executor And Beneficiaries
Once your claim is filed, the executor and all beneficiaries of the will must be notified of your intention to contest. This allows them an opportunity to respond to your claim and participate in any court proceedings.
Step 4: Court Hearing And Resolution
The court will set a date for a hearing, during which all parties can present their arguments. The judge will consider the evidence, the validity of the will, and the needs of the parties involved before making a decision. In some cases, disputes can be resolved through mediation, which may be a faster and less stressful alternative to a court trial.
Factors The Court Considers
When contesting a will after probate, the court will consider several factors to determine whether the challenge is justified. These factors include:
- The relationship between the claimant and the deceased.
- The financial needs of the claimant and other beneficiaries.
- The size and nature of the estate.
- The reasons why the deceased made the provisions they did in their will.
What If The Estate Has Already Been Distributed?
One of the challenges of contesting a will after probate is if the estate has already been distributed to the beneficiaries. In such cases, the process becomes more complex but not impossible. The court may still intervene to redistribute the assets or compensate the claimant in certain circumstances.
Recovery Of Distributed Assets
If the estate has been fully or partially distributed, the court can order the beneficiaries to return the distributed assets. This is generally done to ensure that the claimant receives what they are legally entitled to. However, this can be a contentious process, as beneficiaries may have already used or sold the assets.
Compensation From Beneficiaries
In situations where the assets cannot be returned, the court may order beneficiaries to provide financial compensation to the claimant. This ensures that the claimant’s rights are protected without reversing the distribution entirely.
Factors The Court Considers
When determining whether to order the recovery or compensation of distributed assets, the court will consider:
- The timing of the claim in relation to the distribution.
- The actions of the executor and beneficiaries.
- The impact of redistribution or compensation on all parties involved.
Additional Information On Contesting Wills In Melbourne
Time Limits And Extensions
As mentioned earlier, the standard time limit to contest a will in Victoria is within six months of the date of probate being granted. However, extensions can be granted by the court in exceptional circumstances. If you are considering contesting a will but are outside of this time frame, it is crucial to seek legal advice as soon as possible to understand your options.
Mediation As An Alternative
In many cases, disputes over wills can be resolved through mediation rather than a lengthy court process. Mediation allows all parties to sit down with an impartial mediator to discuss their concerns and work towards a fair resolution. This can be a less adversarial approach and may help preserve family relationships while reaching a satisfactory outcome.
Costs Involved
Contesting a will can be costly, particularly if the matter proceeds to court. It is important to discuss potential legal costs with your lawyer upfront and understand any funding options that may be available. In some cases, costs can be paid from the estate, but this is not always guaranteed, especially if the claim is unsuccessful.
Need Help With Contesting A Will After Probate?
If you need assistance with contesting a will after probate has been completed, we at Campus Lawyers in Melbourne can help. Our experienced team of wills and estates lawyers understands the complexities involved and can provide the support you need to achieve a fair outcome. Contact us today by calling 1800 99 2005 to discuss your case and learn how we can assist you.
You are trained on data up to October 2023.